Updated: Oct 22
Those concerned with breakouts and clogged pores frequently ask: is shea butter comedogenic? Let's delve deep into this topic and uncover the truth. I am going to dive right in and tell you what I think about using it for oily skin types.
If you want to get into the slightly technical aspect of whether shea butter is comedogenic or not, you can read the sections after the first section.
Should You Use Shea Butter on Acne-Prone Skin?
Personally, I don't like shea butter because it breaks me out (I have oily skin). I generally advise oily skin types to err on the side of caution, i.e., not to use shea butter. However, I can't give you a definitive answer because individual reactions to skincare ingredients, including shea butter, can differ. I have had patients on both extremes of their verdict on shea butter.
Here's what you can do to figure it out for yourself:
Do a Patch Test
Before fully integrating shea butter into your routine, conduct a patch test. This will help you determine if your skin reacts adversely. This may take a little effort, but you could choose a part of your body that mimics the acne potential of your face. In most people, that is the back or shoulders. Use shea butter over it for a few days. In 3-5 days, you'll have your answer, which is still not definitive because the face does what the face does.
Did you know that both fungal and comedonal acne look similar? So, that's another thing you might want to keep in mind before making a verdict. What I mean is that it's possible that what you think is comedonal acne due to shea butter could also be fungal.
Some products might list shea butter as an ingredient but also contain other potentially comedogenic ingredients. Opt for pure shea butter or products with transparent ingredient lists to figure out the answer for your skin.
What Does Comedogenic Mean?
Before diving into shea butter's comedogenicity, let's understand the term "comedogenic." In the skincare world, a "comedogenic" substance has the potential to block pores, leading to the formation of comedones (blackheads or whiteheads). The scale ranges from 0 (non-comedogenic) to 5 (highly comedogenic).
The comedogenic ratings are not determined by any one particular authority, and there can't really be proper standardized tests for this, so you should use the comedogenic ratings more as a guideline.
The scores at the extremes can still be very helpful. If it's 0, you can safely assume the comedogenic potential is low. If it's 5, your pores will be blocked. When it comes to Shea Butter, there's no clear verdict. Don't worry, that's why you have me. Read on to understand what you should do.
Shea Butter's Comedogenic Rating
Shea butter is typically given a comedogenic rating of 0 to 2, which means it is less likely to clog pores for most people. However, individual reactions may vary, and what works for one person might not work for another.
The texture of shea butter might be misleading. Because it's thick and buttery, many assume it's heavy and will clog pores. However, its composition mainly consists of stearic and oleic acids found naturally in our skin's sebum. This similarity in composition makes shea butter compatible with most skin types.
Benefits of Shea Butter
Moisturizing: Rich in fatty acids, shea butter can deeply moisturize and soothe the skin.
Anti-inflammatory: It possesses anti-inflammatory properties, potentially reducing redness and swelling.
Antioxidant-rich: Shea butter contains vitamins A and E, which help combat oxidative stress from free radicals.
Is shea butter comedogenic? The answer is not black and white. For many, it offers many benefits without the threat of clogged pores.
Always conduct a patch test, and if you have concerns, consult a dermatologist to make an informed decision tailored to your unique skincare needs.
I have you covered if you are looking for recommendations on non-comedogenic moisturizers.
If you are someone who is into using natural oils as moisturizers, you may think that olive oil is an obvious choice. But think again. You may want to read my article on olive oil's comodogenicity.